Showing posts with label James Bond. Show all posts
Showing posts with label James Bond. Show all posts

Monday, November 30, 2015

Spectre



"You're not going to let me in there, are you?  You've got your armor back on.  That's that."

- Vesper Lynd, Casino Royale

The pathology of James Bond's various personality quirks has always existed in the deep, deep margins of the film franchise, rather than in the text (or even subtext).  The films have first and foremost presented a version of lifestyle porn for the Playboy-era man, a vision of a dashing, debonair man with exquisite taste in clothes and booze and cars and girls who, in between indulging his own personal appetites, also manages to save the world from malevolent, stateless actors.  A person has to work pretty hard to form anything remotely resembling a fully-formed character out of the bits and pieces of Bond we're given in these films, partly because Bond films are infamously overstuffed with all that lifestyle porn and jetsetting, and partly because the films don't have anything resembling a coherent idea of who Bond actually is.

The miracle of the Daniel Craig era, the hardest reboot in the franchise's history, is that he, and the producers, managed to find new things to say about this character after 20 film outings.  In particular, Bond's relationship to Vesper Lynd and to Judi Dench's M helped to give the character something resembling human emotions as he grappled with the loss of both of those women from his life.  The clothes and the cars and the exotic locales are all still there, but by allowing Bond to be an agent at the beginning of his career rather than a perfectly attuned and efficient killing machine, he has been given vulnerabilities that inform the character in rewarding ways.

But it couldn't last.  Sooner or later, the franchise-ness of this multi-billion dollar film franchise was probably always going to overwhelm the interesting new bits, as everyone involved starts to get weary of this character and the necessary bits of business expected of a James Bond film.  When Vesper told Bond that his armor had gone back on in Casino Royale, she could have been talking about the film series as a whole - eventually, the series finds its way back to all of its old tricks and tropes, a set of armor that it puts on so that it can avoid asking the hard questions about who Bond really is, and whether the series' conception of him as the avatar of post-Cold War Western benevolent hegemony actually makes any sense, instead choosing to marinate in all the superficialities that it probably rightly believes has turned it into said multi-billion dollar franchise.  Mendes and company ask the question of what this modern version of Bond would look like in an old-fashioned Bond picture, and the answer turns out to be an absolutely catastrophic clash of tones.

We begin in Mexico City, where Bond, after a pretty interesting single-take scene that takes him from the streets up to the rooftops, gives chase to and eventually kills one Marco Sciarra, a man who he kills (we later learn) at the posthumous behest of Judi Dench's M, who also tells him to attend the funeral.  This brings him into the orbit of Spectre (they've ditched the SPECTRE acronym since they last appeared, which makes writing this review actually more difficult, since the film and the organization share the exact same name) which is headed by one Franz Oberhauser, a man who, it is later revealed, grew up with Bond when they were children and who was believed to have died decades ago.  After barely escaping from Spectre's goons, including the silent Mr. Hinx, Bond makes his way to Austria to find the dying Mr. White from both Casino Royale and Quantum of Solace, and Bond promises that he will protect White's daughter, Madeleine Swann, in exchange for information that will lead him to the Spectre hierarchy.  With said daughter's help, Bond manages to track down Oberhauser who, in the film's worst kept secret, has refashioned himself one Ernst Stavro Blofeld and who, in league with Joint Intelligence Service head and M's current boss Max Denbigh, has created a program called Nine Eyes, which unites most of the world's intelligence and surveillance information and allows Spectre access to it.  After some light torture by Blofeld, Bond and Swann manage to blow up Blofeld's base, and they head back to London to stop Denbigh from activating Nine Eyes.  Denbigh and Nine Eyes both meet their maker at the hands of M and Q, but Swann and Bond are kidnapped by Blofeld's henchmen, and just barely manage to escape the demolition of the old MI6 building, after which Bond brings down Blofeld's helicopter and M arrests him.

I'm going to need a minute after that recap, God.  Hang on.

Bond films generally do little more than glance at current events, holding them up to a funhouse mirror where whatever is currently in the zeitgeist is simply another step on the path towards the villain.  SPECTRE, in its original incarnation, was a way for the film series to nod towards Cold War politics before revealing that whatever plot had been set in motion was the work, not of the Soviets or the West, but of an extra-national terrorist organization that was happy to allow either side to blame the other.  The upside of this sort of sleight of hand is that it means that the films are rarely explicitly political, which helps them from becoming complete relics.  When they have ventured into the political realm, like they did with 1997's Tomorrow Never Dies and its thinly-veiled Rupert Murdoch stand-in, they are dated almost instantly, because this series is just not built to say anything terribly interesting about global politics.  The fact that Spectre's plot takes on, pretty directly, concerns about the surveillance state, does not work in its favor, because the film has essentially no perspective other than "minute, global surveillance is bad if it's explicitly conducted against the people who need to root out the villains controlling it".  M hand-waves towards the idea that it's better to live in a world in which assassins have to look their victims in the eye rather than pushing a button on a drone, but his case isn't particularly convincing considering that his own assassin has been responsible for just an absolutely uncountable amount of civilian deaths and property destruction.

But the meat of this film has very little to do with Spectre (the organization's) plot, and everything to do with the cat and mouse chase between Bond and Blofeld.  Blofeld, as per his usual custom, is a barely-seen figure through the first two-thirds of the movie, before he and Bond finally meet in the third act.  It is at this point that Blofeld exposits that everything that has happened through the first three movies of the Craig era, from the death of Vesper Lynd to Mr. Green's South American water scheme (whatever it was, I can't even remember now) to M's assassination at the hands of Raoul Silva was Spectre's doing all along, explaining that Quantum was nothing but a smaller piece in the larger Spectre hierarchy.  Which, I get why they insisted on putting everything under the Spectre umbrella retroactively after acquiring the rights to use it, because Quantum was never anything but a thinly-disguised Spectre analog anyway, but the whole thing really reads as Blofeld pretending to be responsible for shit that he had nothing to do with.  Blofeld doesn't lay out missing pieces to the puzzle so much as say names and say, yeah, that was me, and that was me, and that other thing was me too.  It is, in a word, stupid.

And it is also predictable, which could describe every single beat of this movie.  Bond beds the widow of a man he killed, extracting information from her.  Bond meets a much younger woman who at first rejects his advances but is eventually worn down by his charms.  Bond defeats the villain but the villain survives because there are still 30 minutes left in the movie.  The man heading the new intelligence agency, played by the guy who plays Moriarty as a snivelling little weasel on "Sherlock", turns out to be a snivelling little weasel in league with Blofeld.  The girl gets kidnapped and Bond has to save her.  The villain is brought down by his own hubris.  Not a single beat of this movie takes even so much as a tiny deviation from where you think it will ultimately go.

It would be hard to overstate just how disappointing the return of Blofeld turns out to be.  Now, the dirty little secret about the original version of Blofeld is that he isn't really all that menacing as a bad guy, which isn't helped by the fact that he gets slowly neutered over three movies of having his plans foiled by James Bond.  So even in his original incarnation, his menace is more implied than actualized, and the previous movies in the series leading up to his reveal in You Only Live Twice, from Dr. No through Thunderball, where he was named but not seen, do a lot of the heavy lifting there.  But they do ultimately do that heavy lifting, and they put us in a place that, when we finally do meet him, we can fill in a lot with our imaginations, because the ground has been previously laid.  So sticking him in this movie, with neither him nor Spectre having ever been mentioned before, provides a challenge that the 1960's movies didn't have, to make Spectre and Blofeld menacing in a single film's space of time, a challenge that could have been overcome if Blofeld was as well-realized as Le Chiffre or Raoul Silva had been.  But, with all due respect to Christoph Waltz, his performance is so dull, and so dependent on the revelation that he was secretly responsible for everything bad that has happened up to this point, that Blofeld makes almost no impression.  Instead of being the culmination of four movies' worth of intrigue, he ends up deflating not only his own movie, but in a small way the three films that have come before.

The torture scene is a perfect reflection of everything that went wrong in the making of this movie.  Start with this - a chair, a pocketknife, and a leather whip.  That is the entirety of the arsenal that Le Chiffre needs to torture Bond in Casino Royale, and the pocketknife is only needed to cut a hole in the chair before Le Chiffre goes to town on a naked, bloody Bond.  That scene is visceral and raw and fits the aesthetic of Craig's Bond to a T.  Compare that to Spectre's Blofeld, who has an elaborate, computer-controlled dentist's chair that he uses to drill holes in Bond's skull.  That's gruesome on paper, sure, but it's also complicated and weird and never once seems like the sort of thing that would, or could, ever exist in reality.  That's Old Bond, and some things in the past should stay in the past.

And that brings me to the triumphant return of the sexist/racist axis.  Because this movie is deeply sexist, in the insidious way that certain modern blockbusters that think they are enlightened are actually just old-fashioned, sexist throwbacks.  Sure, the film would never do anything as gauche as what they did to Britt Ekland's Mary Goodnight in The Man With The Golden Gun, turning her into an absolute bumbling idiot.  What they do is simply constantly pull the rug out from under Lea Seydoux's Madeleine Swann, whether it be in the scene on the train where she saves Bond from Dave Bautista's Mr. Hinx (yay!) and then immediately has to be saved from Hinx by Bond (boo!), or in the finale where she is literally the damsel in distress that Bond has to save.  The theme, as always, is "predictable".  Bond always deals the final blow to the villain, Bond always ultimately saves the girl more often, and in more impressive ways, than she saves him.

I am genuinely unsure of where Bond goes next, which is in stark contrast to my optimism post-Skyfall.  The new status quo, with Blofeld's Spectre as the overarching threat, is boring and untenable, and needs to be fixed or written out, whether Craig returns or not.  Starting over with a fresh actor wouldn't be the worst thing in the world, except another reboot of the series this soon after Casino Royale would be a real step backwards.  I would prefer to see Craig go out on a high note, with a film that allows his Bond to end on a note of grace, but Spectre botched the arc of his films so deeply that I'm afraid it might be too late.  D+

Saturday, December 8, 2012

James Bond - A Reckoning



I want to wrap up my thoughts on the series before moving on to my next project, so I want to do a few rankings lists and then do some superlatives encompassing the sublime and the ridiculous of the series, the racist, the sexist and the ever so occasionally enlightened.

Film Rankings


On Her Majesty’s Secret Service
Goldfinger
Skyfall
Casino Royale
The Spy Who Loved Me
GoldenEye
From Russia With Love
You Only Live Twice
For Your Eyes Only
Dr. No
The World Is Not Enough
The Living Daylights
A View to a Kill
Live and Let Die
Thunderball
Licence to Kill
Tomorrow Never Dies
Diamonds are Forever
Die Another Day
The Man With The Golden Gun
Quantum of Solace
Octopussy
Moonraker

Song Rankings

Diamonds Are Forever
On Her Majesty’s Secret Service
Goldfinger
A View to a Kill
Nobody Does It Better (The Spy Who Loved Me)
GoldenEye
Live and Let Die
Skyfall
The World Is Not Enough
The Living Daylights
Thunderball
For Your Eyes Only
From Russia With Love
You Only Live Twice
You Know My Name (Casino Royale)
Tomorrow Never Dies
Moonraker
Licence to Kill
Another Way to Die (Quantum of Solace)
Die Another Day
The Man With The Golden Gun
All Time High (Octopussy)

Villains

Blofeld, You Only Live Twice, On Her Majesty's Secret Service and Diamonds Are Forever
Auric Goldfinger, Goldfinger
Le Chiffre, Casino Royale
Franz Sanchez, Licence to Kill
Rosa Klebb, From Russia With Love
Raoul Silva, Skyfall
Doctor Kananga, Live And Let Die
Elektra King, The World Is Not Enough
Aristotle Kristatos, For Your Eyes Only
Brad Whitaker, The Living Daylights
Alec Trevelyan, GoldenEye
Dominic Greene, Quantum of Solace
Scaramanga, The Man With The Golden Gun
Dr. No, Dr. No
Hugo Drax, Moonraker
Max Zorin, A View To A Kill
Emilio Largo, Thunderball
Karl Stromberg, The Spy Who Loved Me
Elliot Carver, Tomorrow Never Dies
Kamal Khan, Octopussy
Gustav Graves, Die Another Day

Bond Girls

Wai Lin, Tomorrow Never Dies
Melina Havelock, For Your Eyes Only
Teresa di Vincenzo, On Her Majesty's Secret Service
Pussy Galore, Goldfinger
Vesper Lynd, Casino Royale
Aki, You Only Live Twice
Tatiana Romanova, From Russia With Love
Eve, Skyfall (yes, I know what I said in the review, but Eve fits better in this list)
Pam Bouvier, Licence To Kill
Camille Montes, Quantum of Solace
Holly Goodhead, Moonraker
Solitaire, Live And Let Die
Kara Milovy, The Living Daylights
Anya Amasova, The Spy Who Loved Me
Jinx Johnson, Die Another Day
Octopussy, Octopussy
Domino Derval, Thunderball
Natalya Simonova, GoldenEye
Honey Ryder, Dr. No
Stacy Sutton, A View To A Kill
Tiffany Case, Diamonds Are Forever



Christmas Jones, The World Is Not Enough









Mary Goodnight, The Man With The Golden Gun


Film that was the most pleasant surprise - For Your Eyes Only
Film that was the most bitter disappointment, awful Bond girl division - The Man With The Golden Gun
Film that was the most bitter disappointment, general division - Diamonds Are Forever
Most forgettable film - The Living Daylights
Favorite Blofeld - Donald Pleasance, You Only Live Twice
Worst Blofeld stand-in - Karl Stromberg, The Spy Who Loved Me
Best opening stunt - Bond skis off a cliff with a Union Jack parachute, The Spy Who Loved Me
Most embarrassing opening scene - Bond drops Blofeld down a chimney, For Your Eyes Only
Most destructive stunt - Bond destroys most of St. Petersburg with a tank, GoldenEye
Best song marred by a terrible singer - "You Only Live Twice", Nancy Sinatra
Worst song elevated by a great singer - "GoldenEye", Tina Turner
Worst attempt to make a white person look Asian - Bond in yellowface, You Only Live Twice
Worst attempt to turn an Asian character into a white person - Colonel Moon/Gustav Graves, Die Another Day
Coolest casino scene, baccarat division - Bond's very first appearance, at Le Cercle at Les Ambassadeurs, Dr. No
Coolest casino scene, non-baccarat division - Bond and Eve in Macau, Skyfall
Saddest casino scene - Bond playing blackjack by himself, Licence To Kill
Best first half - Casino Royale
Best second half - On Her Majesty's Secret Service
Most deflating first half - Dr. No
Most deflating second half - Moonraker
Favorite Bond girl in an otherwise awful film - Wai Lin, Tomorrow Never Dies
Worst Bond girl in an otherwise stellar film - Natalya Simonova, GoldenEye
Best use of underwater filming - The submarine car, The Spy Who Loved Me
Worst use of underwater filming - Basically the entirety of Thunderball
Best stunt filming - The opening scene, Skyfall
Worst stunt filming, non-CGI division - All of Quantum of Solace
Worst stunt filming, CGI division - The kiteboard escape, Die Another Day
Best use of an alpine setting - Blofeld's mountain hideaway, On Her Majesty's Secret Service
Worst use of an alpine setting - Bond snowboards to a brutal cover of "California Girls", A View To A Kill 
Most racist against Asians - Goldfinger
Most racist against black people - Live And Let Die
Most racist against white people - Quantum of Solace
Favorite Q moment - Q threatens Bond with murder if he doesn't bring the car back in one piece, Tomorrow Never Dies
Most upsetting Q moment - Q has to deliver the re-entry quip, Moonraker
Bond dresses like a clown memorial mention - Octopussy
Coolest use of a circus - Just kidding, no such thing.
Dirtiest Bond girl name - Plenty O'Toole, Diamonds Are Forever
Most inexplicable Bond girl name - Tie, Christmas Jones, The World Is Not Enough and Strawberry Fields, Quantum Of Solace
Most surprisingly competent Bond girl despite a ludicrous name - Pussy Galore, Goldfinger
Coolest climax - Bond and M protect this house!, Skyfall
Worst climax - Space lasers, Moonraker
Weirdest climax - Bond chases Scaramanga through his funhouse, The Man With The Golden Gun
Plot twist that actually upends the meaning of the film - Elektra King is actually the Big Bad, The World Is Not Enough
Plot twist that adds absolutely nothing to our understanding of the film - Colonel Moon becomes a white person, Die Another Day
Coolest boss base - The volcano, of course, You Only Live Twice
Crappiest boss base - Max Zorin's blimp, A View To A Kill
Best henchman - Jaws, The Spy Who Loved Me
Worst henchman - Jaws, Moonraker

Friday, December 7, 2012

Skyfall



Note: I am going to spoil the everloving shit out of this movie, and it is one of a very small handful of Bond films that can actually be spoiled.  If you do not want to have this happen, then come back once you've seen it.

Since about 1990, the most common state of the Bond film series has been "troubled", thanks to MGM's recurrent financial difficulties.  They held up the production of GoldenEye (and hastened the end of the Dalton era), played a role in the decision to reboot the series with Casino Royale (and the exit of another actor) and delayed the production of Skyfall while MGM went through bankruptcy proceedings.  Quantum of Solace was rushed into production in order to cash in on the success of Casino Royale, but Bond laid fallow for 4 years after that, the longest break in the series that didn't involve a role recasting.

Sam Mendes was hired to direct Skyfall very early in the development process, and the rumor mill constantly swirled around whether he was going to leave the project or not as MGM struggled to get its financial house in order.  In the end, of course, Mendes stuck around, and the end result was a film that not only reversed the massive decline of Quantum of Solace, but legitimately lands the film in the top 5 of the entire series.  I'm going to nitpick this movie, because that is what I've signed up for, but it is a fantastic piece of action cinema, marrying interesting character beats with well-shot, competently edited action scenes.  Skyfall's success paves the way for the Bond film series to live indefinitely into the future, and since I don't think there's any real clamor for the Bond series to pick an end date in order to wrap up its mysteries (who, exactly, is the mysterious person who tailors such incredible suits?), that's probably something that no one will really complain about.  I look forward to coming back in a few years to cover "The Hildebrand Rarity"*

* May not be the actual title.

Let's do the plot first, shall we?  Bond and inexperienced but enthusiastic MI6 agent Eve are on a mission to recover a stolen list of undercover intelligence operatives from some asshole.  During the course of the mission, Eve ends up shooting Bond, who falls off a bridge and into presumed dead status, and the asshole escapes with the list.

MI6 headquarters gets infiltrated and blowed up real good, forcing the department into a more (supposedly) secure underground headquarters and Bond out of his self-imposed exile (surprise - not dead).  Bond is forced to recondition himself, and despite the misgivings of a (seemingly) craven bureaucrat played by Ralph Fiennes, M sends Bond back into the field and after the asshole (whose name is Patrice, so I'll stop calling him that, but really.)

Bond follows the leads up the food chain until he eventually gets to Raoul Silva, a former MI6 agent played by Javier Bardem.  Silva is bent on revenge against M for abandoning him to torture at the hands of the Chinese, and he puts a plan into place to kill M at a public hearing into her part in allowing the list to get stolen, and although he is unsuccessful he manages to escape, so Bond takes M to his ancestral home in Scotland, to hole up and make a stand against Silva on friendly ground.  Silva arrives, is thwarted by Bond, but manages to, in the movie's big surprise, kill M before being killed by Bond.  Upon Bond's return to London, Fiennes' character (who had proven himself to be more than just a bureaucrat, and has earned the trust of our heroes) has been installed as the new M, and Eve has been revealed to be Moneypenny.  M asks Bond if he's ready to continue his work on Her Majesty's Secret Service, and he says he is, roll credits.

So I have to get this out of the way first, and that is the smallness of Silva's plot.  He goes to all the trouble of acquiring this NOC list (Mission: Impossible up in this piece!) just so he can terrorize and humiliate M (he murders some of the people on the list, and makes sure he publicizes that fact), with the ultimate goal being to get up close and personal with her so he can kill her.  The stakes of the movie, which start very high with an enormous list of undercover operatives being stolen, eventually telescope into something very small, with Bond's job simply to protect M's life.  This is a defensible choice from the standpoint that it allows for some real character revelations for Bond and especially M, but for those who complain that it makes Bond's mission seem kind of petty and small well, I sympathize with that criticism.

While I was personally somewhat underwhelmed by the big parkour set piece in Casino Royale, I find absolutely nothing to complain about in this film's opening action sequence.  This is simultaneously one of the coolest and one of the most batshit things Bond has ever done:


I'd also ask you to notice the composition of that scene.  Notice how well the geography is established, and how the scene has a kinetic action pace without relying on shaky-cam gimmickry.  The question going into this film was whether Mendes could handle Bond-style action.  Well, there's your answer.

While I'm at it, of course, I have to mention Roger Deakins, who is Sam Mendes' go-to cinematographer (and who is more famous as the Coen Brothers' regular lensman.)  It is impossible not to notice how great this film looks from beginning to end, and people have rightfully pointed out two scenes in particular, Bond's fight with Patrice on the top floor of a Shanghai highrise with neon images shimmering and swirling in the background, and the nighttime battle at Skyfall (the Bond estate) with Silva and his henchmen.  The former scene, in particular, represents a really creative way to indulge in some theatrical Bond film set design without having to break suspension of disbelief with a volcano base or its equivalent (I'll come back to the latter scene in a bit).

Some people probably love the theme song; I like it, that is all.  It's the best theme of the Craig era by a mile, and Adele proves why she was the perfect choice to sing it, but there's something a little sterile about the song.  An above average Bond theme, no doubt, but not an upper echelon one.



There is a legitimate debate about who the primary Bond girl in this film actually is, and I am in the camp of those who say that it's actually M (the other possibilities are Naomie Harris's Moneypenny, and Berenice Marlohe's Severine).

Severine is the person who actually leads Bond to Silva, and Marlohe is unquestionably in the mix for hottest Bond girl ever.  For an underwritten role, Marlohe does some good work giving the character a bit of depth, and it is probably the film's worst moment when she is unceremoniously killed by Silva.  This is the third straight film where the secondary Bond girl gets killed in really shitty circumstances for the explicit purposes of showing the audience just how bad the bad guy actually is, and it's a trope that needs to be put out to pasture.

For someone who often has chemistry problems with female costars, Craig really got linked up with a couple of solid ones with Eva Green's Vesper Lynd and now Naomie Harris.  The onscreen connection between Bond and Moneypenny has never been as smolderingly sexy as it is here, and the idea of Harris's Moneypenny continuing to show up to flirt with Bond and take him down a peg or two when needed makes me very happy.

What to do with Javier Bardem?  I'm still not sure if his performance is just the right amount of crazy, or too over the top.  The scene where he throws a bit of gay-panic shade at Bond when they first meet is pretty stupid, I will grant that, but Bardem really gives Silva a degree of menace that is often missing from this series.  Even though we only see him commit the one cold-blooded murder, he gives off a distinctively Lecter-ian vibe.  And I think his classic Bond villain deformity is perfectly creepy.

Q!  The return of Q!  As some cocky little computer savant!  Oh, this is very nice.  Ben Whishaw's dumb, floppy hair is absolutely the perfect cherry on our new Q sundae.  I wish he had cooler gadgets for Bond than a little GPS tracker and a gun that gets one use out of its unique property and then is immediately lost, but new Q is a pitch-perfect update of the character.  Yes, thank you John Cleese, your services will no longer be necessary.

Does Bond have to go to a bitchin' Macau casino?  Damn right.  Does he have to wear a perfectly-tailored tux to go there?  You bet your ass.  Does he play baccarat while he's there?  Well, two out of three ain't bad.

The film, being released in the 50th anniversary year of the Bond flicks, is chock-full of references to old Bond movies like Die Another Day was, but since I've only seen it in the theater I didn't really have a chance to make note of them.  The only one that everyone remembers, and it's a doozy of a cool scene, is when Bond opens the garage door in which sits the car that he plans to take M to Scotland in, and it reveals the Aston Martin from Goldfinger, complete with passenger-side ejection seat.

I guess I have to cover the second big, "I don't really get why they did this" part of the film, and that is the reveal of Bond as the scion of a castle-owning Scottish family that he apparently was estranged from before his parents' death.  Like I mentioned in the Casino Royale review, this undermines the background that Vesper imagines for Bond (and hers seemed much more plausible than this, that he was an orphan with anger management and self-control issues who MI6 targeted young).  I believe that Skyfall's posited background for Bond squares with Ian Fleming's, so I can't complain too much, but I certainly preferred the other background better.  Bond as an up-from-his-bootstraps orphan who takes to the finer things in life as almost a defense mechanism is more interesting than Bond as an aristocrat who was born into a knowledge of clothes and wine and good food but was too much of a self-involved brat to stick around and help manage the estate.

Yes, the final scene has some pretty clear Home Alone overtones, and everyone can enjoy making those jokes.  More importantly, though, it represents a really interesting inversion of the usual "assault the base" climax of a typical Bond film.  The base here is being guarded by, not the bad guys, but the heroes, and the villain is the one who brings a strike force to help get him in.  Like most people I am somewhat confused as to why Albert Finney is in this movie (he plays the gamekeeper of Skyfall, and helps Bond and M protect the estate against Silva and his men) but, hell, he's an actor with all sorts of gravitas, and he gives Craig a chance to do some pre-assault banter, so why not.  Like I mentioned earlier, it is one of the most beautifully composited scenes ever done in a Bond film, with the Bond manor being put to the torch against a pitch-black night sky.  And the action here, if you can get past the Home Aloneness of it all, is really well done, with the various makeshift booby traps that our three heroes set off to kill the bad guys helping to give the scene a real underdog flavor.  Our good guys are fighting for their lives, and every time they catch another henchman in a trap it's impossible not to feel a thrill.

I have mostly not commented on the women's fashions in these movies, because I am even less qualified to talk about them than I am the men's fashions.  I'll make an exception for Moneypenny's dress that she unveils at the end, which is a very nice little Easter Egg, a clear shoutout to the dresses that Lois Maxwell used to wear.  I'm a little disappointed that Moneypenny immediately gets stuck behind a secretary's desk after a single film in the field (I thought it would have been a nice right turn for the film to suggest moving her behind the desk before rejecting that idea and keeping her out in the field) but I look forward to how they manage to work her character into the film series.  This Miss Moneypenny is capable of so much more than sitting in M's office and flirting with Bond, and even if she only gets to do the sort of backup work that she does in the Macau casino scene (where she's another set of eyes for Bond, and she flits in and out of the scene while maintaining a constant stream of dialogue with Bond; it's a really cool scene, and I'm not doing it justice), well, at least that would be something.

Back in his English Patient, heartthrob days, you wouldn't have thought that Ralph Fiennes would one day be perfectly cast as a grey English bureaucrat, but you'd have been dead wrong.  It's the hair that does it.  After he asks Bond if he's ready to continue his work, we get a gunbarrel scene, the Bond theme kicks in, and the film cuts to the credits.  And I realize that I'm a total hypocrite for how much I loved this despite the fact that I hated it with a burning passion in Quantum of Solace, but I will rationalize it by pointing out that Skyfall represents a genuine evolution in the Craig era, with a new M and Moneypenny and Q now all on board, whereas Quantum of Solace represented just a boring status quo ante, with everything winding up the same way they did at the end of Casino Royale, with all the same beats repeated.

Bond sleeps with Severine, and although I like the character a billion times more than I liked Strawberry Fields, she is also here in part because none of the other women in the film were sexually available to Bond, and he has to sleep with someone.

Thursday, December 6, 2012

Quantum of Solace



Here are the men who directed all of the Bond films through the Dalton era:

Dr. No - Terence Young
From Russia With Love - Terence Young
Goldfinger - Guy Hamilton
Thunderball - Terence Young
You Only Live Twice - Lewis Gilbert
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - Peter Hunt (the oddball film, in basically every sense)
Diamonds Are Forever - Guy Hamilton
Live and Let Die - Guy Hamilton
The Man With The Golden Gun - Guy Hamilton
The Spy Who Loved Me - Lewis Gilbert
Moonraker - Lewis Gilbert
For Your Eyes Only - John Glen
Octopussy - John Glen
A View to a Kill - John Glen
The Living Daylights - John Glen
Licence to Kill - John Glen

Hunt only did the one film as director, but he edited the first five.  Other than him, you have basically 4 "house" directors of the franchise (Young, Hamilton, Gilbert and Glen), people who stuck around for multiple films and were part of a larger James Bond team, with producers and editors and whoever else creating fully collaborative films.

Since the beginning of the Brosnan era, the directors of the films have been more of the "gun for hire" sort, men (and, again, always men) who come on for a film, give it as much of their personal style as the franchise allows, and then move on to other things.  I have mostly not talked about the directors in these recaps (with the odd shoutout here or there to Martin Campbell) because for the most part they are kind of incidental actors, people who bring a certain tone to the film but mostly just set up the action and the story and let it happen.  But Quantum of Solace cannot be talked about without coming to terms with Marc Forster's job as director.  I don't know any other way to say it - the film is incompetently directed.  Forster is not, all things considered, a hack of a director.  I liked Finding Neverland enough, even though I'd never watch it again, and Stranger Than Fiction was an oddball little lark.  But he botched Quantum of Solace so completely that he simply can't escape notice here.  He should not have been hired to make this picture.  There is certainly a good Bond flick to be made with the raw materials he had to work with here, and there's still a salvageably okay Bond flick peeking out at the margins of this film.  But, given just what's on screen, this is a terrible Bond movie.  It is saved the ignominy of being the worst film in the series only because the depths of the Moore era still exist, and can't be wiped away.  It is the worst non-Moore movie in the series, and that is an amazing feat considering how effectively Casino Royale pulled the franchise out of its late-Brosnan era tailspin.  I mean, I legitimately found basically nothing to like about this movie, and even with a turkey like Moonraker I thought there were decent elements in the first half of the film.

But, since I have set myself the task of going through these films with a fine-toothed comb, and since I am so close to the finish line, I will go once more into the breach, and bullet point this horrid piece of shit.

The opening scene sets the table with utter perfection, in that it is an incoherent mess of shaky-cammed, poorly-edited action that goes from nowhere to nowhere.  Bond is in a car, he has the mysterious Mr. White from the end of Casino Royale in the trunk, and he is being chased by some villains that he I guess dispatches of.

Cut to the Jack White-penned song, which also features Alicia Keys.  Picking gems out of turds - I like the opening guitar riff of the song.  I like not a damn other thing about it.  Supposedly Amy Winehouse was the first choice of the filmmakers, but she was (unsurprisingly) not in the sort of shape that would be required, and couldn't do it.


The plot, so far as it goes - in our only direct sequel in the entire franchise, Bond goes tracking after the shadowy organization, named Quantum, that was responsible for bankrolling Le Chiffre and also Vesper Lynd's death.  The trail leads him to one Dominic Greene, a slimy little creep played by Mathieu Amalric, who apparently represents some high level of the organization.  Greene is engaged in a scheme to replace the Bolivian government with some petty Generalissimo - in exchange, he forces the General to hand over water rights in the entire country to Quantum.  Along the way, Bond links up with Camille Montes, a woman whose family was killed by the General when she was a little girl and who is bent on revenge against him.

Two massive problems here.  Number one, Quantum is clearly meant to evoke SPECTRE.  That organization was the villain in 6 of the first 7 Bond films (Goldfinger's the odd man out) before vanishing from the series due to copyright issues.  We met SPECTRE slowly, getting a little piece of the organization here and a little piece there, but starting with From Russia With Love, we always knew we were on the trail of a man named Blofeld, who headed this organization, and we knew generally what they were after (massive extortion schemes through terrorism.)  Quantum, on the other hand, is just a big cloudy ball of nothing.  Who is Greene?  Who does he work for?  What, ultimately, is his aim?  The organization doesn't come into any sort of focus at any point.

Number two is the scheme around which this movie is based.  I don't mean to sound petty and provincial but, honestly, who gives a shit about water rights in Bolivia?  This is what Quantum wants to spend its time dicking around with?  Let 'em.  This is a big planet, with a lot of dangerous people in it, and Bolivia is a small country and, seriously, I'm falling asleep just thinking about the smallness of this horseshit.

So anyway, during the interrogation with Mr. White Quantum reveals its existence and that it has people everywhere, and M almost gets shot.  There's a chase scene with Bond and some Quantum operative and it features some cool ideas, including a mid-air brawl suspended on ropes, but it is so completely botched by the awful shaky-cam, quick edit, Bourne-aping direction.  Did I mention Bourne-apery?  That is the strongest theme of this dumb movie.  The final shot of the scene is actually alright (it got featured in all the trailers) with a dead-eye shot from Bond directly into the camera to finish off the bad guy.

Judi Dench is still doing good work here, God bless her.  It's funny to think back to the Brosnan era and remember how little use the films made of her, and even though she's playing the same character here it's almost as if she isn't, because M is an actual character in the Craig era, and not just an exposition machine.

Another thing that pisses me off about this movie - it is, on some level, a Tomorrow Never Dies redux, with Bond tracking a weedy little doofus that he immediately suspects of being a bad actor for really no particularly good reason.  I mean, he certainly has an idea that Greene has some place in the Quantum organization, but he hates him on a visceral level well before we see him do anything much but be mean to his girlfriend.

That girlfriend is the aforementioned Camille Montes, played by Olga Kurylenko as a variation on the Melina Havelock archetype, only more exotically multi-cultural.  The problem is that Havelock's revenge quest was triggered by something that happened on screen, whereas Montes' is described solely through exposition, so it does not have anywhere close to the same impact.  We know she hates this guy, and we know why, but it never really coalesces.

Quantum holds a meeting by having a bunch of their operatives attend the same opera and speak into ear pieces.  It's a reasonably cool update of the old-school, theatrical (literally, in this case) villain meeting, usually taking place around a table in some impossible underground (or underwater) structure.  It is, of course, marred by another awful action set piece that doesn't make any sense.  Besides the shaky cam and the quick-cut editing that doesn't allow for any sense of geography, Forster keeps cutting to the opera on stage, and to this giant eye that forms the focal point of the set, for reasons that only he could possibly explain.

We meet Strawberry Fields, our secondary girl, at the La Paz airport.  Bond has gone off the reservation in pursuit of Greene and Quantum, and she shows up to bring him back home. She originally takes Bond to some fleabag place in town to hole up for the night before catching a flight back the next day, but he bullies his way into an upgrade at some classic Bond swankorama hotel and really, that's just fine.

Strawberry Fields is the worst kind of Bond girl throwback, someone who allows Bond to completely overwhelm her own good sense at all times (besides just having an incredibly stupid, but not terribly ribald, name) and then dying in service of the plot.  She immediately falls into bed with him and it is supposed to be...charming, I guess?  It is not.  Then eventually she is killed offscreen, in a death that is meant to evoke Goldfinger, with Fields all covered in a substance lying facedown on the bed, but instead of gold it's oil.  See, oil is the new gold!  Get it?  Get it?  Fuck.  Fields' only job is to keep an eye on Bond and keep him from escaping for 24 hours, so naturally she lets him go as soon as the opportunity presents itself, because she is a painfully ineffective cipher of a character.

Dominic Greene's cover story is that he's an environmentalist, because it's important to show what a hypocrite he is.  I hate so many things about this movie that the reactionary politics don't even register that much with me but come on.

Since this will be our last Felix Leiter sighting of the marathon, I do want to throw in my little pet theory, which is that Leiter has adventures just like Bond does, where he gets to travel to exotic locations and thwart the maniacal plans of supervillains and screw beautiful women in service of American interests, and Bond shows up occasionally during those adventures to offer a bit of moral support and perhaps some equipment or small piece of intelligence to get his investigation into gear.  Leiter is completely wasted in this movie, spending most of his time pouting that his partner, Moustache McDouchebag, is totally onboard with CIA orders that Greene be cultivated as an ally, rather than investigated as a villain.  And you know what?  Moustache is right.  If the CIA wants to be in bed with scumbags like Greene in order to protect the interests of the US, then that's what they should do.  Leiter isn't some private dick.  He works for Uncle Sam.  This is his job.

At some point, Bond goes flying into the desert after Greene with Montes.  They engage in an (ugly, as if there's any other kind) action set piece involving dogfighting aircraft, and the two of them end up basically free-falling into a gorge after the plane gets shot down.  At the last minute Bond pulls Montes' chute and both of them land hard but alive on the floor of the gorge.  Bond films ask you to suspend your disbelief a lot, and you go with it because they're Bond films, not documentaries.  Yes, Bond can ski off a cliff and pull a Union Jack parachute as he's falling.  Of course he can.  But the way this scene is shot and edited, Bond pretty clearly does not get to the parachute in time to prevent massive injuries to both parties on landing.  It's a small thing, really, but it's another indication of just how little Forster cares about the movie he is making.

Another rare compliment!  The scene where they walk out of the gorge is nice, with Spanish-inflected music on the soundtrack.

So back in La Paz, M is pissed at Bond and orders him suspended and sent back to England under guard.  Bond escapes, as he always does, knocking out a bunch of MI6 operatives and eventually running into M during his getaway.  Immediately, M is back on Bond's side, insisting to anyone who matters that it is important that Bond be given room to investigate Greene.  There is absolutely no justification given for her about face, except that before Bond was in her custody, and now he's managed to escape.

So, whatever, Bond tracks Greene out to some doofy desert hotel, where he and the General are finalizing their arrangement (Oona Chaplin, Talisa from Game of Thrones, has a small role as a serving girl that the General tries to, ugh, rape), and Montes gets her revenge while Bond gets his, the place gets blown up for nebulous reasons, and then something something Vesper Lynd's ex-boyfriend works for Quantum as a fuck machine who gets the female agents of the world's various intelligence bureaus to give up information to him, which Bond puts a stop to.  The Canadian agent that he's working on at the end of the film is played by Stana Katic from Castle, and she has (I believe) one line.

There's a gunbarrel scene tacked on at the very end (there was none at the beginning, which honestly who cares, it is what it is, the Craig Bond doesn't do them anymore, so be it) as if to say, here you go you jackals, this is what you wanted.  The Bond theme plays and then the credits roll, in a direct ripoff of the end of Casino Royale.  Fuck you, Marc Forster.  You are the worst.

Bond sleeps with Strawberry Fields, and it is painfully obvious that she is only in this movie because Bond had to sleep with someone, and Montes was both emotionally and physically unavailable to him.

Monday, December 3, 2012

Casino Royale



In 1999, MGM studios, which has owned the Bond film rights since they bought United Artists back in 1981, acquired the rights to film the novel Casino Royale from Sony (according to wikipedia, the acquisition involved the rights to make a Spider-Man film going back in the other direction, from MGM to Sony, which involved Sony receiving the James Cameron script treatment that eventually turned into the Sam Raimi movie in 2002).  Casino Royale was the big hole in the Bond film canon, the one full-length novel (and Bond's debut to boot) that Eon films had never been able to make a film of.  Things worked out very nicely for MGM in these regards - when Pierce Brosnan walked away (or was forced out, who knows with Bond) after his 4 film deal expired, MGM had the opportunity to recast the part, and reboot the franchise, with the first Bond novel ever written.

Daniel Craig was an inspired choice to play Bond.  He was not a big star at the time - the odds, if there were a such thing, were on Clive Owen, who had a much bigger profile and had already done a bit of a Bond dry-run in Croupier.  Craig has a physical immediacy that none of the other actors who has played the role possesses; you never have any difficulty believing that he could lapse into brutal violence at any moment.  Connery could be brutal, to be sure, but he wasn't physical in the way that Craig is (and his last couple of films, featuring extremely lazy performances, sucked a lot of the edge from the character.)

So it's within this context, with the perfect Bond actor situated in the perfect Bond story, that I have to confess that I was ever so slightly disappointed with Casino Royale on what was my third viewing of the film.    It'll land pretty comfortably in my top five all time, to be sure, but I had placed it as A#1 with a bullet in my mind, and it didn't quite get to that level.  I identified three problems with the film that stuck with me, one minor, one medium and one major, and I'll point them out as I get to them.  I'm not going to recap the plot of the film, because it's pretty straightforward and I'm sure most people have seen it recently enough to remember the general outline.

First things first though, the opening scene might just feature the coolest moment in the entire Bond canon.  We get an intercut scene of Bond's first murder (which is our first "Daniel Craig gets down and dirty" fistfight, though far from our last) with his second, which is cool and clean, and when target number two begins "you needn't worry, the second is..." Bond aces him before he can finish the thought and then says, "Yes.  Considerably."  Fucking awesome.

I don't know whose idea it was to have Chris Cornell sing the theme song (in full-on hunger-dunger-dang rock mode, no less) but it was a very poor choice.  I actually suspect the theme song is decent (and it contains elements of the OHMSS theme, which I've waxed rhapsodic about enough at this point) but Cornell's caterwauling is just awful.

I'll start with my medium problem with the movie, which is that the action never really gripped me.  The most famous stunt is the first one, where Bond chases some living MacGuffin in a fully-realized parkour action stunt scene.  And as much as I admire the scene from a technical standpoint, I never really got much of a thrill from it, unless it were to say, "Bond, it is very high up there, wouldn't you like to get down and perhaps drink a martini."  The most underwhelming action scene, in my mind, is the chase at the airport, where one of Le Chiffre's minions attempts to blow up a brand spanking new jet plane.  It's very drab, and very dark, and cribs a bit too much from Raiders of the Lost Ark for my taste.  It has a funny button at the end though, when the bad guy gets blowed straight up by his own bomb.

Le Chiffre might be the second most famous Bond villain, after Blofeld, and it's a real tribute to Mads Mikkelsen that his performance easily outshines both Peter Lorre's and Orson Welles' in the public consciousness.  Now, granted that both of those men played the character in non-Eon, mostly forgotten films, but Mikkelsen is great in the part, giving Le Chiffre the right mixture of arrogance and petulance.

I wanted to dive into Bond continuity a little bit, so if that's the sort of thing that doesn't interest you (and really, it shouldn't, because it's a very silly thing) then skip this paragraph.  Okay, so, the most straightforward reading of Bond series continuity is that the films proceed in chronological order, with Bond being a single man, born James Bond, who works for M and MI6.  It takes a good deal of suspension of disbelief, of course, with Bond's changing face and the political situation of the world morphing over the course of 50 years, but if you're willing to do that then you start from there.  This movie throws a major monkey wrench into that idea, though, because the Bond of Casino Royale is very clearly at the start of his career (and M uses the line "I knew it was too early to promote you" so you can't really fall back on the idea that the opening scene happened way in the past, and everything else happens in the present).  But in GoldenEye, Bond referred to M's predecessor, meaning she was just starting the job at that point.  So this doesn't square.  A common fan theory, an obvious one, is that James Bond is simply a code name, and that each actor who takes the role is a new man, assigned that name and that number and proceeding through time in a normal fashion.  This would work out perfectly if it wasn't for one problem - Tracy, Bond's late wife, who is referred to by Connery, Lazenby, Moore and Dalton.  Perhaps a hybrid of the two would work, that those four are one man and Brosnan/Craig are separate men from them, but it's all very convoluted and broken at this point (and will only get more broken with Skyfall).  This is not a series for continuity hounds.

Judi Dench immediately has more interesting things to do than she had during the entire Brosnan run.

Bond checks his Sony Ericsson phone so many times that it almost reads as a meta gag about the ubiquity of product placement in the Bond films.

Bond wins his 1964 Aston Martin from some greasy Eurotrash scumbag that he's tracked to the Bahamas and I bet the car stinks like Drakkar Noir and garlic.

The interplay between Vesper Lynd and Bond in their first meeting aboard the train is among the best things that has ever happened in a Bond movie, and it's a little bit of a shame that the family background she intuits for Bond (their interplay is based on each making judgments about the others' background from first impressions) is undermined by Skyfall.  Eva Green makes a very impressive Vesper, and if she doesn't land in my top 3 Bond girls it's only because the character is given too little to do.

There's a real playfulness to Craig's performance that I'd forgotten.  Craig can be a dour, humorless presence on screen, a problem that I think is getting worse (he was the worst thing about The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo), but in this film he is actually pretty damn charming.

The movie implies that Vesper is the first person to ever put Bond in a finely-tailored tuxedo, and man does it look like great.  Latter-day Bond films do not skimp on the tailoring budget, that's for damn sure.

The center of the film, which is the center of the novel, is a card game between Le Chiffre and Bond (plus a bunch of other players, including the return of Felix Leiter for the first time since the Dalton era.)  Then we get to my minor problem, the game.  The trappings of the game are super swanky, featuring Montenegro's coolest hotel and a bunch of dressed up people playing the highest of high stakes cards.  But the game, as you know, is Texas Hold'em, and it is so deeply, deeply uncool.  Not as uncool as the backgammon he played in Octopussy, but uncool enough since it places the film firmly in 2006, when poker was all the rage.  It dates the movie terribly and, worse still, suggests to douchebags like this:


that their chosen "profession" is so cool even James Bond plays it.  They are wrong.  Bond, as a world-class dilettante, plays baccarat, a game of fairly minimal skill, because he doesn't have time to learn proper game-playing strategy while he's memorizing wine vintages, screwing beautiful ladies, and occasionally getting off his ass long enough to save the world.

I love Jeffrey Wright and he, as per usual, makes the most of his limited time on screen as Leiter.

The scene right after Bond kills the two African warlords (who were after Le Chiffre for some money of theirs that he lost shorting airline stock, hence the attempted plane explosion) at the hotel is like no other scene I can remember in any of these films.  The way Martin Campbell shoots the consequences of his violence is really remarkable, with quick cuts of Bond cleaning the blood off of himself interspersed with shots of a decanter and tumbler filled with whisky that Bond downs; he upped his game for this movie.  Then the shot of Vesper and Bond in the shower is done in a single long take, with the scene ending as Bond wordlessly comforts the distraught Lynd as the camera slowly zooms out.

"Shaken or stirred?"
"Do I look like I give a damn."
- A line that singlehandedly adds a half a letter grade to this movie.

The poisoning scene reminds me a lot of the (very goofy) tarantula scene from Dr. No, with a lot of closeups on Bond's sweaty face.  Here it's played totally serious.  Actually, it was played serious in Dr. No, it's just that you could clearly demarcate when Connery was in a shot and when his double was (hint: the double is in scenes where the tarantula actually touches skin).

So, my major problem.  The last 30 minutes or so of the film happen after Le Chiffre has already been offed (he goes out like a total chump, shot by someone who isn't even Bond, but that's sort of the whole point), and Bond and Vesper running off together to Venice, with Bond even turning his resignation letter in to M.  This is all well and good in a film that's just the 21st Bond picture, with Bond getting sucked back in to action courtesy of Le Chiffre's bankrollers (and Vesper's double cross) serving to put a capper on the notion that Bond has to be bury his emotions to adequately do his job.  But it is completely undermined by the fact that this is implied to be Bond's second mission as a 00 agent.  I gather that the novel was supposed to be an in media res opener on Bond's already-in-progress career, so when he runs off with Vesper (and ultimately denounces her after discovering her double cross), it is meant to tell us something profound about Bond's character.  But in a movie where we are asked to believe that Bond has just started his 00 career, for him to immediately throw it away for Vesper suggests something else, that he is impulsive and emotionally attached to basically everyone. I get that this film says, this is who Bond was before he "got religion" and decided to remain closed off to everyone as a means of protection, but it just never squares, for me at least, with the Bond that we've known through 20 films prior.  That Bond turns his charm on and off, not as a means to protect anyone, but because he's easily bored and kind of a dick.  It also kind of sucks that we learn the details about Vesper's betrayal through post-hoc exposition delivered by M - the last 30 minutes are a real rush job after the languid pace of the rest of the movie, with an enormous amount of plot and character dumped into a tiny space, the audience left to sort the whole thing out mostly on its own.

The film suggests (and then follows through with, in the next film) a direct sequel, which I was very excited about at the time it came out.  Stick around to find out how that turns out!

Bond sleeps with Vesper, probably a bunch of times.  He never manages to close the deal with the very sexy  Catalina Murino, who plays Mr. Eurotrash's girlfriend and gets an ugly and very unfortunate Bond Girl Death.

Thursday, November 29, 2012

Die Another Day



I think I have to start with a plot summary first, because there are a lot of details in there that I have to use as jumping off points.  So, we start with Bond on some sort of an infiltration mission in North Korea.  Colonel Moon is the key figure Bond is after here, and after seemingly killing him, he is captured by Moon's father and subjected to 14 months of interrogation and torture in a North Korean prison.

M springs Bond in exchange for MI6 releasing Moon's right-hand man, Zao.  Bond is suspended from MI6, but decides to track Zao anyway, and ends up on the trail of a British billionaire named Gustav Graves.  Graves has an assistant, Miranda Frost, who is an MI6 spy in her own right.

The plot moves to Iceland, where Graves is debuting a new satellite that focuses the sun's energy into a tight beam that can be used to create artificial daylight.  Around here are revealed two twists - Frost is actually a double agent who is working for Graves, and Graves is none other than Colonel Moon himself, back from the dead and sporting a new face.  Graves/Moon plans to use his solar satellite to destroy the mines in the Korean DMZ, allowing the North Koreans to invade the South and reunite the peninsula.  Bond, along with NSA agent Giacinta "Jinx" Johnson, infiltrate this plan and stop Graves/Moon, before flying off into the sunset (and the traditional post-climax screw.)

So I did that whole thing relatively straight and it took all of my willpower because this movie floats upon a vast, vast ocean of serious stupid.  The plot moves along at a reasonably brisk pace so it's not a difficult film in the series (Bond films aren't difficult, per se, but some of them slow to a complete crawl, really trying my patience; Die Another Day does not), but just about everything that happens in this movie carries some degree of stupid along with it.  There's a legitimate argument that this movie is the stupidest film in the series so far, and that is a tough list to crack indeed.  As per usual, here is a list of things.

The opening scene brings together two of the world's most uncool things: hovercrafts, and North Koreans.

The film, to its credit, goes way off model after that scene, with Bond's captivity forming the basis of the opening credits sequence (and Bond himself going all beardy/long hair during his time in prison).  The fatal flaw here, of course, is that it's scored to Madonna's execrable theme song, which is just as off-model but in the wrong direction.  One thing that probably isn't her fault is the lyrics, which are quite possibly the worst in the entire franchise (although I bet the thing about Sigmund Freud was her adlib, because she is a dumb person who thinks she's smart, and that's the sort of thing a person like that would come up with.)



In the first post-credits scene, Brosnan's Irish accent starts to really peek out.  Chalk it up to laziness, I guess?  I'm not sure.

There's a swordfight between Bond and Graves that is actually a really great action setpiece and both actors acquit themselves well but it also makes them both seem like crazy people, with the two of them going at it with maximum violence despite the fact that none of the proper stakes of the movie have been revealed yet, and the stakes of the swordfight were set up as a simple wager.  They break the everloving shit out of a ton of stuff at Graves' fencing club despite the fact that they are supposed to have never met each other (and Bond, at this point, hasn't the faintest clue who Graves actually is - he just knows he's up to no good, and that he has a sneer-y, punchable face.)

Die Another Day was filmed in 2002, and it is implied by M that Bond was in captivity through 9/11.  The bad guys in the movie are the North Koreans, which is immediately a really terrible choice.  You've got the shadow of 9/11 hanging over the film (Bond is almost entirely dedicated to fighting terrorists, going way back), and granted that the film couldn't (and shouldn't) make a bunch of middle Easterners the bad guy, but they eschew terrorism entirely for the stupid North Koreans.  There's a reason they were the bad guy in that Trey Parker/Matt Stone puppet movie, and that is because they are not really a threatening country, they are just silly and deeply weird.

The twist in The World Is Not Enough made a certain degree of sense, because it upended our expectations about what a woman is capable of in a Bond film.  The twist in this film, where Colonel Moon becomes a sneering white person out of nowhere, is absolutely awful.  Leaving aside the continuity issues that it obliquely dicks around with (I will touch on continuity when we get to the next film), given that we are now told for absolute fact that in the James Bond universe a person can completely change their appearance and voice (a popular fan theory about why Bond/Blofeld/Moneypenny/Leiter constantly change appearances), the twist does nothing plotwise except remove one (Asian) actor to bring in another (white) actor.  It's a twist which introduces magical science that completely breaks suspension of disbelief for the purpose of stalling the villain's reveal for about 30 extra minutes.  And Toby Stephens' performance as Graves is way over-the-top obnoxious.  Your best Bond villains have a real charm to them, slowly luring you into their web (to borrow a phrase), and Stephens spends the whole movie begging for a good solid cock-punching.

This was both the 40th anniversary of the franchise and the 20th Bond film, so they took the opportunity to lard the film up with callbacks to previous films.  There's a single scene in Q labs that is a treasure trove of callbacks (and here is John Cleese as our full-time Q; Desmond Llewelyn, like Bernard Lee before him, doesn't seem to have received any sort of in-film memorial, despite the fact that he died between films.)  Here's a very partial list of some of the callbacks I noticed throughout the film.

Breathing apparatus (Thunderball)
Laser trap for Jinx (Goldfinger)
Jinx emerging from the water (Dr. No)
Union Jack parachute (The Spy Who Loved Me)
"Diamonds are forever" quote in magazine
Mirror room (The Man With The Golden Gun)
Rosa Klebb's knife shoe from From Russia With Love
Jetpack from Thunderball
The autogyro from You Only Live Twice

I don't want to get too deep in the weeds about the virtues of practical vs. computer generated effects, because CGI has in fact given us plenty of great scenes in a wide variety of movies and it is, quite frankly, here to stay whether anyone wants it to be or not.  But this movie really makes the case that the entire concept of CGI should be nuked from orbit with one of those highly radioactive nukes that keeps anything from growing there for thousands of years.  There is a scene where Bond escapes from the space laser on a makeshift kiteboard and it would have looked more realistic if it had been done in stop-motion, Clash of the Titans style.

The one thing everyone probably knows about this film is that there is an invisible car in it.  What's there to say that hasn't already been said?  It represents the absolute rock-bottom of Bond gadgetry, and it would probably single-handedly ruin the film if there weren't about two dozen other things that could easily make the same claim.

I don't know anything about director Lee Tamahori but I know he is really fond of those "fast, then slow" camera swoops that were all the rage in the early-00's.

There was serious talk during/after the release of this film about making a spinoff film featuring Halle Berry's Jinx.  Here's the part where I confess that I don't really like Halle Berry.  I guess I liked her well enough back when she was just a minor star with a cute girl-next-door thing going on, but then everyone got obsessed with telling her how sexy she is all the time, and she won an Oscar for that godawful Billy Bob Thornton movie, and by that point she had become a Really Huge Star without any of the requisite charisma to pull it off.  So I don't particularly like Jinx as a character or a Bond girl, but I am biased against her.  She also has to deliver some atrocious lines, both a "yo mama" crack and also the line, "Read this, bitch!"

That being said, she is still significantly better and more interesting than Miranda Frost.  The less said about her, the better.  It is exposited that the reason she turns double agent is because she was in the same fencing class as Colonel Moon in college.


The geopolitics of this movie posit that the only reason the North Koreans don't invade South Korea is because of the minefield in the DMZ, and that by destroying the mines with the giant space laser, South Korea is basically a sitting duck to the mighty North Korean army.


The British/American alliance (basically M and a very distracting Michael Madsen as some higher-up at the CIA I guess) shoots one missile directly at the heart of the laser satellite.  It is easily destroyed, because it is a laser satellite, and no one thinks to just launch a bunch of missiles on different trajectories at the stupid thing, since it can only shoot in one direction at a time.

Bond sleeps with both Jinx and Miranda Frost.  He fake sleeps with Moneypenny in a virtual reality simulation that Moneypenny has using a pair of dumbass training glasses that easily make the list of the aforementioned two dozen other things that also ruin this awful movie.

Monday, November 26, 2012

The World Is Not Enough


I've tentatively planned to do a superlative list when I'm done with this marathon, with some obvious categories and some not so obvious categories.  Without giving too much away, I'd say that the movie that was the least pleasant surprise so far was The Man With The Golden Gun, which is not really an objectively terrible Bond movie (it's mostly just static and low-stakes and boring) but which has one of the all time "fuck you" Bond girls, a character so dumb and unpleasant that she brought the entire film down around her.

Anyone who's seen this movie has already figured out where I'm heading with this, but let me vamp for a little bit longer and say this - I had assumed that the Brosnan era was a continuous downhill slide, starting with the very good GoldenEye and plummeting to the indefensibly campy Die Another Day (I have not watched that movie yet, but I know its reputation perfectly well).  And I think that the major lesson I took out of The World Is Not Enough is that not only is it a significant improvement over Tomorrow Never Dies, but it's actually an above-average Bond flick.  It's not great, but it does enough things well that I'd watch it a million times over again before I suffered through Tomorrow Never Dies again.

But there is that one thing, probably the most memorable thing (for all the wrong reasons) about the film, and that is the former Mrs. Charlie Sheen as Dr. (ha!) Christmas Jones.  And let me be clear, I am not going to say anything nice about her, not her character or her performance.  Well, one thing - she is, at least in her pre-Sheen days, an unquestionably attractive woman, one who looks really great in a wet white T-shirt.  Denise Richards' blank-faced prettiness had been utilized very well in Starship Troopers, where the point is supposed to be how hollow both she and Casper van Dien were as people.  And I could take or leave Wild Things, but she's certainly well-cast in that movie, where all she really had to be was a sexpot willing to suck face (and take her top off) with Neve Campbell.  So she has her extremely limited uses.

Bond movies aren't exactly fonts of capital-A acting, and Richards isn't a significantly worse actress than some of the other bottom-shelf Bond girls, but what she does represent is a degree of contempt for the audience that is really unbecoming.  It's one thing to suggest that a pretty girl can also have a Ph.D. in nuclear physics, but it's quite another to suggest that a pretty girl who can't register anything more than a vacant expression as she rattles off science-y speak and who is, let's be honest, pretty clearly a dumb person in real life, could have a Ph.D. in nuclear physics.  Casting Richards as this character was contemptuous, a signal from the filmmakers that they believe their audience are simpletons who will accept their idea of an "updated" Bond girl, where the film simply tells us she is smart without needing to do any of the work of showing us because she is pretty and we are stupid.

Christmas Jones, whose name exists solely for Bond to make an awful pun at the end of the film, is by far the worst part of this movie, and fortunately most of the other parts are decent, and some of the parts are great.  The plot, in its simplest form, revolves around the villain sabotaging a key oil pipeline, increasing the value of their own pipeline dramatically.  Nuclear weapons are involved and it all gets very convoluted, as these movies usually do, but that's the basic outline.  Bond saves the day, makes a pun at Dr. Jones, and the movie ends.  As usual, I will bullet point the rest.

The opening stunt is exactly as loud and flamboyant as the opening stunt in GoldenEye is (mostly) quiet and simple.  But it works really well on its own terms, and is a major improvement over Tomorrow Never Dies' lackluster opener.  It's divided into two parts, and there's a fakeout where after the first part, Bond goes back to MI6 HQ without the opening theme kicking in, so you know something is up.  That something is one of M's friends (who, naturally, we have never seen nor heard of before) getting blown up and Bond chasing the assassin down the Thames in, admittedly, a pretty goofy-looking boat.  Regardless, it is one of the all-time great openers.

The theme is also a significant improvement on Tomorrow Never Dies (this is kind of a running theme), with Shirley Manson doing a pretty good update of the classic slinky, sexy Bond theme singer.


Sophie Marceau plays the daughter of the aforementioned blowed-up-real-good friend of M's, Elektra King, a woman whose previous kidnapping at the hands of Robert Carlyle's Renard is the kernel around which the entire plot of the film is built.  I admit that I generally find Sophie Marceau pretty sexy, so I am probably overrating her here, but I think she's a solid presence.

She and Bond engage in a ski chase with a bunch of dudes in these strange paraglider/snowmobile combo things, and it is another piece of evidence in favor of the idea that any time you can put Bond on skis you will probably end up with a quality action scene.

Carlyle's performance is turned down a bit low, especially given the elaborately weird backstory of Renard (he has a bullet in his brain that means he can't feel pain).  And his character is completely neutered by a mid-film twist.

I may be mistaken, but I think this movie has the first genuine twist in the entire series, when it's revealed that Elektra is the shadowy power behind all the film's mayhem (including blowing her own father up) since she and Renard had become lovers during her kidnapping ordeal.  She holds a particular grudge against M, since M was the person encouraging her father not to simply give in to Renard's ransom demands, and although this is an excuse to get Judi Dench a few more scenes (Elektra kidnaps her and puts her in a makeshift Bond Trap), it is mostly a massive dud that she is dragged into the plot.  M also, for the first time in Dench's run, has to do the old "seeing Bond screwing the final girl after the plot has been resolved" scene and it is a lot less fun for someone of her acting pedigree to have to feign bemusement at Bond's fairly tiresome cocksmanship than it was when Bernard Lee was doing it.

Goldie is in this movie, entirely for comic relief.  That is very strange.

The quality of the action in the movie kind of evaporates after the two scenes I mentioned (the opening bit and the ski scene) and by the time we get to the final boss battle on a submerged submarine, there is virtually nothing particularly interesting happening on screen.  Now that I think it about it, it may be due to just how much Christmas Jones is involved in the action in the second half of the movie.  Richards sucks the life out of the film when she is on screen.

I'm not really sure if I have anything to say about Brosnan's performance.  He's a steady hand at the wheel who doesn't really bring anything extra to the table.  Workmanlike, I guess, is how I'd describe him.  I guess I might have to admit that I sense him getting sick of the part here, as most actors do eventually.  Brosnan in some ways always felt a little too perfectly cast in the role, a man who is so effortlessly suave that it's almost hard for him to really bring anything extra along with.

John Cleese gets introduced as the guy who is obviously meant to replace Desmond Llewellyn's aging Q.  I don't really have anything positive to say about this decision - Q is obviously the goofiest of the main characters in the Bond universe, but he is also supposed to be something of an engineering and science savant, and you have to believe that he is both easily exasperated and incredibly smart in order for a lot of his very arch scenes to work.  Cleese can do goofy and he can do exasperated but the savant part has now been tossed aside and that kind of ruins the whole idea of Q.

While it's really cool that we finally get our first female Big Bad, Bond dispatches her well before the final conflict without any fanfare (she's offed by a gunshot), and then has a long drawn out battle with Renard (which is incredibly boring in part because of how the reveal of Marceau as the top dog of Eviltown turned Carlyle's character into nothing more than a lackey.)

Given what a contemptuous character Christmas Jones is, I'm willing to bring back the sexist/racist index for a one-night-only engagement.  Extremely sexist, certainly the most sexist Bond movie since the depths of the Moore era.  And while it's nice that Elektra King drives the plot, the film treats her with a degree of casual indifference that is incongruous with her place in the broader story.

Bond sleeps with both King and Jones, and I don't think anyone else.

(I'm reading through this review and thinking, boy, this is really negative given that I've expressed that I actually liked the movie.  On balance, the good outweighs the bad, but a lot of the good happens in the first half of the movie and a lot of the bad happens in the second half, so what I most clearly remember is the bad.)

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Tomorrow Never Dies


Let's talk about Karl Stromberg, the villain from The Spy Who Loved Me.  His plot, which Bond eventually foils, involves intentionally starting World War 3 so that he can begin civilization anew from his underwater base.  Insane?  You bet.  But it comes by its insanity honestly; Stromberg is really into what's under the sea, and he doesn't particularly like people, and he just doesn't feel like fucking around any more.

Elliot Carver, the villain played by Jonathan Pryce in Tomorrow Never Dies, also has a plan to trigger World War 3, or at least the opening stages of it (it turns out that his plan involves installing an ally at the top of the Chinese government who, it is exposited, will put the lid on the actual nuclear holocaust of the entire planet by diplomatic means).  But Carver, a transparently-Murdochian media mogul, doesn't want to do anything as grandiose as restart civilization in his own image from the bottom of the sea (Carver, it should be noted, also has a penchant for underwater basery).  All he wants is exclusive broadcast rights in China.

None of this is really kept from the audience - from the very beginning, we know Carver is behind the film's mayhem, and by the time he has fully explained the scope of his plan, there wasn't anything in it that came as a surprise.  I know I use the word "stupid" a lot in these reviews, granting that the Bond series dips deeply in the well of stupidity a lot, often on purpose.  But this plot, I feel like I can safely say, takes the series to a level of stupidity that it has heretofore failed to achieve.  Carver risks global nuclear catastrophe, his own personal reputation, and his life, all for the purposes of (slightly) increasing his market share.  Everything in the film flows from this decision, to make this extremely late-90's plot the driving force of the movie, and so everything else here has to work to dig the film out of its deep hole (spoiler alert - it doesn't make it.)  Bullet points follow.

The theme song to this film may actually be decent but I can't tell, because Sheryl Crow sings it with marbles in her mouth.  I don't know who decided that Crow fit the Bond series but they were 100% wrong.

The first time we meet Carver he is talking to a gigantic wall of monitors and he is, naturally, discussing a wide variety of evil plans to the giant faces on the screens.  The only thing missing from the scene would be for the camera to pan out to reveal that he was strangling an orphan while he talked.

Pryce is an okay character actor who should not have been allowed within 100 miles of a Bond villain.  His performance is really atrocious, aiming for "delightfully megalomaniacal" but landing much closer to "One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest".  This...I don't know what the fuck this was:



Moneypenny has to deliver a "cunning linguist" gag and M gets to tell Bond to "pump (Teri Hatcher's character) for information."  I remember when GoldenEye came out there was a lot of talk about M's one big scene where she calls Bond a misogynist dinosaur, so the filmmakers were certainly aware that they were making a series about a sexist relic, and yet they still do shit like this.  It's not even so much the sexism that bothers me as it is the unbelievable lameness of the puns.

Let me paint you a picture.  James Bond, relaxing in his swanky hotel room after a long day of seduction and spying.  His tuxedo is partially unbuttoned but still looking very dashing, and on the table next to him are a bottle and a gun.  He waits, eagerly, for whatever mischief Carver is planning to send his way tonight.  Periodically, he pours a shot from the bottle and downs it in a single gulp, the weariness in his soul slowly dissipating from the warm caress of the alcohol.  The label on the bottle is red.  It reads "Smirnoff".  These movies started to become very expensive in the Brosnan era so the producers lined up as many sponsors as they could, but the idea that Bond is drinking some mass-market swill like Smirnoff Red Label straight has Ian Fleming's body spinning like a top.

Hatcher plays a complete cipher of a character who exists to slap Bond once, sleep with him, and die.  Her performance lives up to this billing precisely.  She does look sexy from the back in just her underwear, though, so there's that.

When Bond finds Hatcher's corpse in his hotel room, on the TV in the room is playing a tape of a news report about both her and Bond's death, to be broadcast later that day (because her assassin is sitting there waiting for Bond, and that's the sort of game Carver likes to play).  Keeping in mind, again, that this is the sort of ridiculous thing that happens in these movies, just imagine the logistics of that.  Gathering together a whole news crew, writing a script for a pair of deaths that haven't happened yet, getting it in the hand of your assassin to play as one last "fuck you" to Bond.  The number of people who could theoretically piece together that Carver knew of both deaths before they happened is enormous, and all so he could deliver a meaningless threat to a guy who he was going to kill anyway.

The assassin is played by character actor all-star Vincent Schiavelli in the mold of a classic Bond villain; he brags about his marksmanship and has a Dr. Strangelove accent.  It's a funny scene from his perspective - Schiavelli is playing it for high comedy and it works.  Brosnan, unfortunately, is giving him nothing to work with as a straight man.  Where the scene calls for a light, playful touch, Brosnan is all anger and sharp edges. This is Brosnan's performance in a nutshell - usually good enough from scene to scene, but tonally incoherent.  He seems to want to play Bond in the rougher mode of Daniel Craig or even Timothy Dalton, but the scripts are all Roger Moore quippery.

The worst thing about the overall suckiness of this movie is that it overshadows what I will put up as my dark horse favorite for best Bond girl of all time, Michelle Yeoh's Wai Lin.  She is capable, she is sexy, she does her own goddamned stunt work.  She is, in a nutshell, 8 different degrees of awesome, and while the movie doesn't get any smarter once she finally becomes a full-time part of the plot at about the 2/3 mark, it certainly becomes a hell of a lot more fun.  None of her stunts quite use her to her full capabilities (her first stunt comes the closest, where she and Bond take a handcuffed motorcycle ride through the streets of Saigon, and she has to switch positions with him a couple of times mid-ride) but she does get to kick and punch a whole bunch of dudes and it is delightful.  I love Wai Lin.  I wish she was in a movie that wasn't awful.

Bond bones two women, some random Danish blonde and Hatcher's character whose name I haven't mentioned yet but really who cares? (it's Paris).